Kit Kat Vs Reese’s Sticks Vs Nutty Buddy: What’s The Difference?
If you love the combination of crispy wafers and chocolate, chances are you’ve reached for a Kit Kat, a pack of Reese’s Sticks or a Nutty Buddy at some point. At first glance, these three treats look quite similar. They’re all made with layers of crunchy wafer and covered in a chocolate coating. But take a bite, and you’ll quickly notice the differences. From their fillings and coatings to their texture, history and where you’ll find them in the store, here’s how these three wafer favourites compare.
Kit Kat: The Classic Chocolate Wafer
Kit Kat is one of the world’s most famous chocolate bars. It was first created in 1935 in York, England, by Rowntree’s, and is known for its iconic “break off a piece” design. In the U.S., Kit Kat is made by Hershey under licence, while Nestlé makes it in most other countries.
A standard Kit Kat has four fingers of crisp, light wafer layered with a thin cream filling and coated in milk chocolate. There’s no peanut butter here. The flavour is all about the balance between airy wafer and smooth chocolate. Kit Kat also comes in a huge range of flavours and limited editions, from dark chocolate to seasonal specials.
Best for: Chocolate lovers who want a light, crispy, classic treat.
Reese’s Sticks: Peanut Butter Meets Wafer
Reese’s Sticks, also made by Hershey, take the familiar crunch of a wafer bar and add Reese’s famous peanut butter. Each stick features crispy wafer layers filled with peanut butter and coated in milk chocolate.
The result is a richer, more indulgent bar than a Kit Kat, with a salty-sweet flavour that will be familiar to anyone who loves Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. The peanut butter gives each bite a creamier texture, while the wafer keeps it crunchy and light.
Best for: Fans of Reese’s who want peanut butter flavour with extra crunch.
Nutty Buddy: The Lunchbox Favourite
Nutty Buddy wafer bars are made by Little Debbie, the snack cake brand owned by McKee Foods. They’ve been around since 1964 and were originally sold as Nutty Bars before being renamed Nutty Buddy around 2016.
Each bar has four wafers sandwiched together with a peanut butter mixture and covered in a chocolatey coating. Unlike Kit Kat and Reese’s Sticks, which use milk chocolate, Nutty Buddy uses a chocolate-flavoured coating, which gives it a slightly different, sweeter taste and softer snap. Nutty Buddy bars are typically sold in multipack boxes in the snack cake aisle and are one of Little Debbie’s three best-selling products.
Best for: Budget-friendly snacking and nostalgic lunchbox treats.
Kit Kat vs Reese’s Sticks vs Nutty Buddy at a Glance
| Feature | Kit Kat | Reese’s Sticks | Nutty Buddy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | Hershey (U.S.), Nestlé (most other countries) | Hershey | Little Debbie (McKee Foods) |
| First introduced | 1935 (UK) | More recent addition to the Reese’s range | 1964 (as Nutty Bars) |
| Wafer | Crisp, light wafer fingers | Crispy wafer layers | Four wafer layers |
| Filling | Thin cream filling | Reese’s peanut butter | Peanut butter mixture |
| Coating | Milk chocolate | Milk chocolate | Chocolatey coating |
| Flavour | Classic chocolate wafer | Rich, salty-sweet peanut butter | Sweet peanut butter and chocolate |
| Where to find it | Candy aisle | Candy aisle | Snack cake aisle |
| Best for | Light chocolate treat | Peanut butter lovers | Budget-friendly multipacks |
What Are the Biggest Differences?
The main difference comes down to the filling. Kit Kat focuses purely on chocolate and wafer, while both Reese’s Sticks and Nutty Buddy add peanut butter. The second big difference is the coating. Kit Kat and Reese’s Sticks are coated in milk chocolate, while Nutty Buddy uses a chocolatey coating.
Texture also varies. Kit Kat is the lightest and crispiest, Reese’s Sticks are richer and creamier thanks to the peanut butter, and Nutty Buddy has a softer, sweeter bite. Finally, you’ll find Kit Kat and Reese’s Sticks in the candy aisle, while Nutty Buddy usually sits with Little Debbie’s snack cakes, often sold in value multipacks.
Which One Should You Choose?
- Choose Kit Kat if you want a classic, light chocolate wafer without peanut butter.
- Choose Reese’s Sticks if you love peanut butter and want a richer, more indulgent bar.
- Choose Nutty Buddy if you want an affordable, nostalgic peanut butter wafer treat that’s great for lunchboxes.
The Bottom Line
Kit Kat, Reese’s Sticks and Nutty Buddy all share a love of crunchy wafers and chocolate, but each offers something different. Kit Kat is the timeless chocolate classic, Reese’s Sticks bring rich peanut butter flavour, and Nutty Buddy is the budget-friendly lunchbox favourite. The best one simply depends on your taste, so why not try all three and decide for yourself?
FAQ
What is the difference between Kit Kat and Reese’s Sticks?
Kit Kat has crispy wafers with a thin cream filling and milk chocolate coating, while Reese’s Sticks add Reese’s peanut butter between the wafer layers for a richer, salty-sweet flavour.
Is Nutty Buddy the same as Nutty Bars?
Yes. Little Debbie originally sold the snack as Nutty Bars before renaming it Nutty Buddy around 2016.
Who makes Kit Kat in the United States?
Hershey makes Kit Kat in the U.S. under licence, while Nestlé makes it in most other countries.
Does Nutty Buddy use real chocolate?
Nutty Buddy bars are covered in a chocolatey coating rather than the milk chocolate used on Kit Kat and Reese’s Sticks.
Bolded anchor phrases to link: Kit Kat, Reese’s Sticks, Nutty Buddy, Hershey, wafer, milk chocolate, peanut butter, McKee Foods, Nutty Bars, chocolatey coating.
Source: Click here to view source
