This year, be thankful for canned pumpkin puree

Picture a farmhouse kitchen in the 1790s, a few days before a harvest feast. There’s no can opener on the counter and no food processor in the corner. Someone has to split a heavy pumpkin, scoop out the seeds, cook the flesh down, and then press it through a sieve by hand until the stringy fibers stay behind. Only after all that does the actual pie-making begin.

Today most of us crack open a can and call it done. A recent Popular Science piece by Allison Futterman traces how one of America’s fussiest desserts became one of its simplest. Here’s that story, with the key dates and figures gathered in one place.

Pumpkin pie started as hard labor

Early cooks didn’t take shortcuts because there weren’t any. One New England cookbook from 1876 told readers to simmer pumpkin for six to eight hours, stirring often, and then rub it through a colander. All of that went into a single pie meant to feed about eight people.

Penn State food scientist John Coupland called the effort “astonishing,” and the reason is simple. Pumpkin flesh doesn’t collapse into a silky paste on its own. Heat softens it, but the tough fibers stay put until something physically breaks them apart. In the 1700s and 1800s, that something was a tired pair of hands.

Where the recipe came from

Squash wasn’t new when Europeans arrived. Indigenous peoples across North America grew it and cooked it in many forms. Colonists quickly adopted pumpkins as a dependable, plentiful crop, and English cookbooks were already printing pumpkin-filled pie recipes in the 1600s.

The earliest known American recipe appears in Amelia Simmons’s American Cookery (1796), widely regarded as the first cookbook written in the United States. Her “Pompkin Pudding” combined cooked, strained pumpkin with milk, eggs, and spices. Swap the spelling and it reads a lot like the custard pie many families still bake.

How Thanksgiving put pie on the national menu

The holiday’s origin story usually begins in 1621, when English colonists and members of the Wampanoag people shared a three-day harvest celebration. The tidy classroom version tends to skip the colonization and conflict that followed.

Thanksgiving didn’t become a national holiday until 1863, when President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed a national day of thanks. That moment owed a lot to Sarah Josepha Hale, a magazine editor who lobbied for decades. Hale believed a shared day of gratitude could help pull a divided country together, and she used her pages to promote a traditional New England menu. After the Civil War, pumpkin pie traveled with that menu across the country.

Pumpkin pie timeline at a glance

Year Milestone
1600s Pumpkin-filled pies appear in English cookbooks
1621 Three-day harvest gathering of English colonists and the Wampanoag
1796 Amelia Simmons publishes “Pompkin Pudding” in American Cookery
1835 Elijah Dickinson brings Dickinson pumpkin seeds from Kentucky to Illinois
1863 Lincoln proclaims a national day of Thanksgiving
1876 New England cookbook advises simmering pumpkin six to eight hours
1929 Libby, McNeill & Libby acquires Dickinson & Co.

The factory fix

Industrial processing changed everything. Factories could cook pumpkin in bulk, break it down mechanically, and seal it in cans that kept for months. The hours of stirring and straining moved out of home kitchens and onto production lines.

The variety mattered just as much as the machinery. According to Libby’s company history, farmer Elijah Dickinson carried Dickinson pumpkin seeds from Kentucky to Illinois in 1835. Libby, McNeill & Libby bought Dickinson & Co. in 1929, and the company’s plant in Morton, Illinois, still relies on Dickinson pumpkins grown across several thousand acres in north central Illinois.

Why canned puree is so smooth

Pumpkin cell walls are built from cellulose, hemicellulose, and pectin. Cooking loosens that structure, and mechanical processing breaks it into tiny particles. The variety, the heating method, and the equipment all shape the final texture and moisture.

That’s where the Dickinson pumpkin shines. Coupland notes its puree comes out smooth and even, so nobody ends up picking fibers from their teeth. Carving pumpkins are a poor fit for factories because their fibers resist breaking down. The FDA also lets certain sweet, golden-fleshed squashes be labeled “pumpkin” in canned products, which is why the can’s contents may look nothing like a jack-o’-lantern.

Feature Dickinson pumpkin Carving pumpkin
Species Cucurbita moschata Cucurbita pepo
Skin Tan Bright orange
Flesh Dense, high in solids and sugar Stringy and watery
Puree texture Smooth and even Fibrous, hard to smooth out
Best use Canned puree and pies Decorating and carving

What this means for your kitchen

If you bake from a can this year, you’re skipping a job that once ate up most of a day. If you’d rather start from scratch, choose a small sugar or pie pumpkin instead of a carving variety, roast it rather than boil it to limit water, and blend the flesh well before baking. Either way, the pie on your table carries more than two centuries of history.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long did it take early Americans to make pumpkin pie filling?

A New England cookbook from 1876 called for simmering pumpkin for six to eight hours, followed by straining it by hand, before baking even started.

What is the oldest known American pumpkin pie recipe?

Amelia Simmons’s “Pompkin Pudding,” published in American Cookery in 1796, is the earliest known American version.

What kind of pumpkin is in canned pumpkin puree?

Libby’s uses the Dickinson pumpkin, a tan-skinned Cucurbita moschata variety with dense, sweet flesh. The FDA also allows some golden-fleshed squashes to be labeled pumpkin.

Can I use a carving pumpkin for pie? You can, but expect stringier, wetter filling. Smaller sugar or pie pumpkins give better results.

Source: Allison Futterman, “Early Americans spent over 10 hours making a single pumpkin pie,” Popular Science, November 20, 2026.

Source