Cold hands made a good pie: Thanksgiving treats were baked with love
Some people remember the bakery that made their childhood pies. Jacques Kelly doesn’t, because there never was one. In a column for the Baltimore Sun published November 20, 2026, the veteran Baltimore writer says that as a boy he hardly knew store-bought apple or pumpkin pie existed. Nearly every sweet thing in his house came out of the family’s Oriole-brand oven, made by two sisters who ran the kitchen.
Two sisters, one kitchen
Kelly grew up in a big extended family. His great-aunt Cora and her sister Lily Rose, his grandmother, ran a sunny kitchen with a cold pantry off to one side. The yearly schedule never changed. Thanksgiving meant pie, and Christmas meant cake and cookies.
The sisters were close their whole lives. They went to Eastern High School together, grew up in the 1800 block of North Broadway, and died a year apart. In Kelly’s telling, they made cooking look easy. They often had the bones of a big holiday meal done before he got out of bed.
They didn’t fight, but there was a quiet pie contest between them, and Cora was the unofficial winner. Her crusts were thinner and lighter, she chose her apples carefully, and she was very good with custards and spiced pumpkin filling.
The secret was in her hands
The column’s title comes from Cora’s own explanation. She said her crusts turned out well because she had cold hands, and Kelly adds that this did not mean a cold heart. Any pastry cook will tell you she had a point. Warm hands soften the butter in the dough, and soft butter makes a tough crust instead of a flaky one.
Cora’s skill went beyond pie. Her baking powder biscuits were light enough to soak up butter. She cut them with a teacup, never a coffee cup, and rolled them out on a Vermont marble counter from her brother-in-law, who ran a cemetery marker business. Marble stays cool, which suited her method.
Apples from a ballpark neighbor
Some of the best details are about where the fruit came from. The family lived at Guilford Avenue and 29th Street, right behind Oriole Park, which burned down in 1944. That put them next door to baseball. Tommy Thomas, who managed the minor-league Orioles of the International League, drove in from York, Pennsylvania, every year in a Cadillac with a bushel of York Imperial apples, and they went into the oven soon after.
Every November the family brought a cast-iron apple peeler up from the basement. Kelly also writes about mincemeat. He admits it didn’t look as good as pumpkin or apple, but he soon learned it was a real winner. Mincemeat used to be the star of the dessert table, and Kelly notes it has mostly fallen out of fashion.
Traditions at a glance
| Tradition | What the family did |
|---|---|
| Holiday baking calendar | Pies at Thanksgiving; cakes and cookies at Christmas |
| Star pies | Apple, pumpkin and mincemeat |
| Apple source | York Imperial apples, by the bushel, from Orioles manager Tommy Thomas |
| Key tool | A cast-iron apple peeler, brought up from the basement each November |
| Biscuit method | Cut with a teacup, rolled on Vermont marble |
| Fall preserving | Homemade sauerkraut cured in stoneware crocks |
| Holiday table | Lace tablecloths, cut glass and Stieff silver in the rose pattern |
| Leftovers | Creamed turkey with mushrooms, served over biscuits |
A crock for every season
The sisters didn’t waste anything, even storage. In the fall they cut cabbage and cured sauerkraut in stoneware crocks. Once the crocks were empty, they held Christmas cookies. By the 1950s the family had switched to canned kraut. On special occasions the table got lace tablecloths, cut-glass serving dishes and Stieff silver in the rose pattern.
Kelly also gives a picture of Cora outside the kitchen. She wore Revlon’s “Windsor” nail polish, admired the British royal family and grew Queen Elizabeth roses. She walked to daily Catholic Mass and spent afternoons at a foot-powered treadle sewing machine.
Nothing left but crumbs
All that work disappeared fast. At one point twelve people sat at the table, and the pies didn’t last long. The leftover turkey became creamed turkey with mushrooms, served with Cora’s biscuits.
The column is less about recipes than about the people who made them. Each pie came from someone who picked the apples, kept her hands cool and got up before the rest of the house. For many families, that is still what makes a homemade Thanksgiving dessert worth the trouble.
