Costco Kirkland Vs Poppi: Who Makes The Better Prebiotic Soda?Food News

Costco Kirkland Vs Poppi: Who Makes The Better Prebiotic Soda?

Costco has stepped into one of the hottest drink categories. This month the warehouse club launched Kirkland Signature Prebiotic Soda, its own version of the “better-for-you” sodas made popular by Poppi and Olipop.

It costs about half as much as the name brands, but how does it taste? Here’s how the new Kirkland soda compares with Poppi on flavor, nutrition and price.

What Is Kirkland Signature Prebiotic Soda?

Kirkland’s prebiotic soda comes in an 18-can variety pack with three flavors: Strawberry Lemon, Orange and Cherry Lime. Each 12-ounce can has 35 calories, 5 grams of sugar and 6 grams of fiber.

Those flavors line up closely with some of Poppi’s best-known options, so it’s clear which brand Costco is competing with. Shoppers first noticed pallets of the new cans in warehouses in early November, and photos spread quickly on social media.

Strawberry Lemon: Kirkland Wins

In The Takeout’s taste test, Kirkland’s Strawberry Lemon was the standout. Sweet, tart strawberry comes through first, followed by a bright lemon finish with a light vitamin C tang.

Poppi’s Strawberry Lemon was still the best of the three Poppi flavors tested, but it tasted mostly of lemon-lime with only a hint of strawberry.

Orange: Kirkland Wins

Kirkland’s Orange also beat its Poppi rival. The tester found it rich and slightly sour, with an orange flavor that tastes real and only a faint vitamin note.

Poppi’s Orange was less impressive side by side. Its flavor reminded the tester more of a fizzy vitamin C supplement than a fruity soda.

Cherry Lime: Poppi Wins

This is where Kirkland stumbled. The tester found Kirkland’s Cherry Lime unpleasant, with a medicinal, artificial taste that the fruit flavors didn’t cover. They noted it might be a personal sensitivity rather than something everyone will notice.

Poppi’s Cherry Lime was sweet, tart and pleasantly fruity, and it won this round easily.

Nutrition: Kirkland vs. Poppi

The two sodas are close on nutrition, with one notable difference: Kirkland has twice the fiber.

Per 12-oz can Kirkland Signature Prebiotic Soda Poppi
Calories 35 30–35
Total sugar 5 g 5 g
Added sugar 3–4 g 3–4 g
Fiber 6 g 3 g
Carbohydrates 11–12 g 9 g
Flavors compared Strawberry Lemon, Orange, Cherry Lime Strawberry Lemon, Orange, Cherry Lime

Prebiotic fiber feeds the healthy bacteria in your gut. These drinks are still sodas, though, not health foods. If you’re not used to much fiber, start with one can a day, because higher-fiber drinks can cause bloating in some people.

Price: Kirkland Is Much Cheaper

This is Kirkland’s biggest advantage. An 18-can Kirkland variety pack costs about $14.89, or roughly 83 cents a can. By comparison, a 15-can Poppi pack at Costco is about $23.49, around $1.57 a can. Single Poppi cans at the supermarket can cost $2.50 or more.

If you drink prebiotic soda every day, switching to Kirkland could save you a lot over a year.

The Verdict: Kirkland Wins, With One Exception

Kirkland Signature comes out ahead overall. In The Takeout’s test, its Strawberry Lemon and Orange were better than the Poppi equivalents. It has twice the fiber, and it costs roughly half as much. The Cherry Lime is the weak spot, and Poppi’s version of that flavor is much better.

If you’re a Costco member, the variety pack is worth a try. If Cherry Lime is your favorite, you may want to stick with Poppi for that one.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Costco have its own prebiotic soda?
Yes. Costco launched Kirkland Signature Prebiotic Soda in November 2026, in an 18-can variety pack with Strawberry Lemon, Orange and Cherry Lime flavors.

Is Kirkland prebiotic soda healthier than Poppi?
They’re very similar: both have about 5 grams of sugar and 30 to 35 calories per can. Kirkland has 6 grams of fiber compared with Poppi’s 3 grams.

How much does Kirkland prebiotic soda cost?
An 18-can variety pack is about $14.89, or roughly 83 cents per can, although prices can vary by warehouse.

Which Kirkland prebiotic soda flavor is best?
In The Takeout’s taste test, Strawberry Lemon was the favorite, followed closely by Orange.

Source: Click here to view source