The last elimination before the My Kitchen Rules 2026 top five came down to one point. The Newcastle best friends Zoe and Zac went back to the food they know best, seafood, and only just held on. Victorian couple Tiffany and Giancarlo went home after a baking mistake and some tactical scoring from a rival.

Back Against the Wall at Kitchen HQ

Zoe and Zac came into the cook-off with something to prove. Earlier in the season the judges, Manu Feildel and Colin Fassnidge, had criticised their crumbed swordfish main. Since Zoe is pescatarian, seafood is central to their whole identity on the show, and they had to show they could cook it well.

This time the format was a two-course banquet: a shared main followed by dessert. It was served to the judges and to the other teams, and their scores would decide who stayed.

The Seafood Tower: Big, Bold and Mostly a Win

The pair built a tall seafood platter packed with coastal favourites:

  • Lobster rolls
  • Salt and pepper squid
  • Grilled miso prawns
  • Fresh oysters
  • Chunky chips
  • Pear and rocket salad
  • Tartare sauce

The lobster and miso prawns went down best with the judges. Colin said the duo had clearly taken earlier criticism on board and lifted their cooking. The tartare sauce was the weak point and didn’t add much to the plate. Even so, it was the most confident seafood the pair had served all season.

Dessert Wobbles for Both Teams

Zoe and Zac’s rhubarb and strawberry crumble with custard and rhubarb shards didn’t come off. The judges questioned using strawberries, said the crumble topping wasn’t cooked through, and found the custard flat. Manu asked whether a dish like that belonged at this stage of the competition.

Tiffany and Giancarlo had a worse dessert. Their main of fresh tagliatelle with ragu, braciole di cotica, meatballs, focaccia and radicchio salad was ambitious, and the judges liked the pasta and sauce. It needed more seasoning, though. It also took so long that they hadn’t started dessert by the time the main went out.

That rush cost them. With about an hour left, Tiffany realised she had made her savoiardi biscuits without flour. They plated the strawberry tiramisu anyway, but it had no structure, and Colin compared it to a flat slab of sugar sitting in cream.

Both desserts scored the same from the judges, seven points each.

How Simon’s Scoring Changed the Result

The judges had Tiffany and Giancarlo one point ahead on the mains, so the guest teams’ scores decided the night.

Angus was unwell, so Simon scored alone for the South Australian duo. He said openly that he would mark the team he saw as the bigger threat low and push the other team’s score up. He gave Tiffany and Giancarlo a 3 and Zoe and Zac an 8. Then he told the Newcastle pair they were welcome.

The other guest scores also leaned towards the seafood lovers:

Guest Team Tiffany & Giancarlo Zoe & Zac
Mary and Golden 7 7
Sheridan and Ted 5 7
Harrison and Oliver 4 7
Simon 3 8

That left Zoe and Zac on 27 out of 50 and Tiffany and Giancarlo on 26.

A Warm Goodbye for the Lovebirds

Tiffany and Giancarlo left graciously. They said they were sad to go but planned to keep chasing their food dream together, and Manu sent off his “little lovebirds” with his best wishes.

What’s Next: Ultimate Instant Restaurants

The top five is set: Zoe and Zac, Mary and Golden, Sheridan and Ted, Harrison and Oliver, and Angus and Simon. Next is the Ultimate Instant Restaurant round, where every team has to serve two entrées, two mains and two desserts. Harrison and Oliver host first. Simon’s tactics will likely make for a tense dinner table.

source